MagicListr vs Primelister
Looking for a Primelister alternative? Here’s how the two compare, from each company’s own site, including where Primelister may suit you better.
Side by side
MagicListr and Primelister at a glance
| MagicListr | Primelister | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $19.99/mo on the web (Pro $39.99/mo); founding members $14.99/mo while they stay subscribed. In the iPhone and Android apps, through the App Store or Google Play: $22.99/mo (Pro $45.99/mo) | $49.99/mo, or $399.99 a year ($33.33 a month); 7-day free trial, no credit card required |
| Pricing from a photo | Snap & Price on every plan: it names the item from your photos and prices it from similar eBay listings (100 items a month, 300 on Pro) | Its phone app drafts listings from a few photos with AI, including a price |
| Phone | iPhone and Android apps that post to every store, plus the web app | iPhone, iPad and Android app for AI drafts and automations; crosslisting is done on a computer with its Chrome extension |
| Take-down when it sells | Every plan | Included (unlimited auto-delisting) |
| Stores | eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Vinted, Facebook Marketplace, Shopify and Whatnot (Etsy paused) | Poshmark, eBay, Mercari, Depop, Etsy, Facebook, Grailed and Shopify; its Vinted and Whatnot pages are for automation |
Primelister’s details are from its own pricing page, home page and help docs, checked . Plans change, so check their site too. Primelister is a trademark of its owner; MagicListr isn’t affiliated with it.
The difference
Where MagicListr is different
Crosslist from your phone: MagicListr’s iPhone and Android apps post to every store, not just make drafts.
Less to pay: $19.99/mo on the web against $49.99/mo.
Vinted and Whatnot are among MagicListr’s nine crosslisting stores.
Honestly
When Primelister may suit you better
You want Poshmark, eBay, Depop or Mercari automation that runs in the cloud: Primelister’s automation tools do that.
You sell on Grailed.
You’ll pay yearly: $399.99 a year works out to $33.33 a month.
Questions
MagicListr vs Primelister, answered
Can I crosslist from my phone with Primelister?
Primelister’s app for iPhone, iPad and Android makes AI listing drafts and runs automations; its help docs say crosslisting is done on a computer with its Chrome extension. MagicListr posts to every store from its iPhone and Android apps.
Is MagicListr cheaper than Primelister?
Yes, month to month: MagicListr is $19.99/mo on the web, Primelister’s crosslisting plan $49.99/mo. Billed yearly, Primelister is $399.99 ($33.33 a month) and MagicListr $199.