MagicListr vs Nifty
Looking for a Nifty alternative? Here’s how the two compare, from each company’s own site, including where Nifty may suit you better.
Side by side
MagicListr and Nifty at a glance
| MagicListr | Nifty | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $19.99/mo on the web (Pro $39.99/mo); founding members $14.99/mo while they stay subscribed. In the iPhone and Android apps, through the App Store or Google Play: $22.99/mo (Pro $45.99/mo) | Crosslisting Plus $39.99/mo, Crosslisting Pro $59.99/mo; with Poshmark and eBay automation $69.99–$89.99/mo (save up to 12% billed yearly); larger closets $20/mo extra; 7-day free trial |
| Pricing from a photo | Snap & Price on every plan: it names the item from your photos and prices it from similar eBay listings (100 items a month, 300 on Pro) | AI writes listings from photos (500 or 1,000 credits a month); suggests a price when recent comparable sales exist |
| Phone | iPhone and Android apps that post to every store, plus the web app | No App Store or Google Play app: a home-screen shortcut to its website |
| Take-down when it sells | Every plan | Crosslisting plans ($39.99+/mo), not automation-only ones |
| Stores | eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Vinted, Facebook Marketplace, Shopify and Whatnot (Etsy paused) | eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Etsy and Whatnot; not Facebook Marketplace, Vinted or Shopify |
Nifty’s details are from its own pricing page and help docs, checked . Plans change, so check their site too. Nifty is a trademark of its owner; MagicListr isn’t affiliated with it.
The difference
Where MagicListr is different
Facebook Marketplace, Vinted and Shopify are included. Nifty supports none of them, per its help docs.
Real iPhone and Android apps that post to every store, not a shortcut to a website.
Crosslisting with take-down when it sells for $19.99/mo on the web, half of Nifty’s $39.99/mo Crosslisting Plus.
Honestly
When Nifty may suit you better
You want Poshmark sharing, following and offers run for you every day: Nifty’s Automation plans do that in the background.
You keep more than 1,500 items listed and want AI credits by the thousand (Crosslisting Pro).
Questions
MagicListr vs Nifty, answered
Does Nifty work with Facebook Marketplace or Vinted?
Not currently, per Nifty’s help docs (Shopify neither). MagicListr posts to all three, along with eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Etsy and Whatnot.
Does Nifty have a phone app?
No. Its help docs say it isn’t in the App Store or Google Play; you add a shortcut to its website on your home screen. MagicListr has iPhone and Android apps.
Is MagicListr cheaper than Nifty?
Yes, for crosslisting: MagicListr is $19.99/mo on the web with everything included; Nifty’s Crosslisting Plus plan is $39.99/mo. Nifty’s Poshmark and eBay automation (sharing, relisting, offers) is a separate plan, which MagicListr doesn’t offer.